At 50 Main Street, the mugs and plates waiting on the shelves for someone to paint them were not shipped in from a supplier. Gather Paper & Clay makes its own bisque in-house, and its resident ceramicists throw and fire the pieces before a customer picks one up to glaze. When you pick a bowl to paint for your mother-in-law, a Tuckahoe potter made it first. The gift is local before you put the first brush on it.
Westchester Magazine called Gather a "brand-new spot in Tuckahoe" in its September roundup of art-forward markets. The store is several things in one room: a new-and-used bookshop, a ceramics studio, a market for local makers, and a maker's café. For anyone planning December, the most useful fact about the place is the firing schedule. Painted pieces are ready for pickup in about one to two weeks. That puts the gift-painting window for Christmas between this holiday weekend and roughly the second week of December.
Gather's pottery painting costs $45 per person and is open to ages 3 and up. The price includes one piece of bisque, and you can upgrade to premium bisqueware when you arrive. You pick a piece, choose your glazes and paint it, and the studio does the firing.
Here is the arithmetic. A piece painted on Saturday, November 28, should be ready somewhere between December 5 and December 12, even at the slow end of the studio's estimate. A piece painted on Friday, December 11 reaches the two-week mark on Christmas Day. Anything later is betting on the short end of the estimate. If you have a particular date in mind, ask at the counter when you finish painting. One to two weeks is the studio's estimate, not a promise.
The posted drop-in hours have midday breaks on weekends, so check them before you walk over:
Gather's own page describes painting as first come, first served. The studio's Kilnfire booking page also takes reservations by time block. On a holiday Saturday, a reserved seat takes the guesswork out of a family outing. The weekday evening hours, which run to 8:30, are the easiest time to fit in a visit after work.
Some people want to make the piece from scratch. Gather & Throw is a two-hour wheel session for ages 9 and up at $95, and the calendar lists sessions through Saturday, November 28, including evening slots from 6:30 to 8:30. Also on the calendar for Saturday the 28th is Kids Sewing Club.
For a family, Family Clay Date costs $70 per person for ages 5 and up, and children under 8 must come with an adult. The kids' wheel class costs $85 for two hours. The booking page lists it for ages 8 to 14, and the price covers trimming, glazing and firing one piece, with extra pieces at $20 each. Thrown pots go through more steps than painted bisque does, so a wheel piece started after Thanksgiving is better thought of as a gift for the new year.
Families already enrolled can look at the end of the fall semester. The After School Clay sessions for ages 7 to 14 meet on Fridays from October 16 to December 18 and on Mondays from October 19 to December 14. Fired work is ready the week after the semester ends. For the Friday group, the semester's work comes home around Christmas week. The adult wheel and handbuilding semesters end on dates between December 13 and December 19.
The second half of December is when Gather's calendar matters most to parents. The studio runs handbuilding camps for ages 7 to 14 from 9 a.m. to noon on December 21, 22 and 23, and again on December 28 through 31. Each camp day costs $90 per child. Children enrolled in both a morning and an afternoon session can add lunch supervision for $20. The camps run between the holidays, the stretch when schools are closed and grandparents tend to be visiting.
This fits how the business started. Founder and creative director Jessica Potenza spent her career in the equine industry before she became a painter. In 2023 she founded Sprouts, a youth enrichment program. Gather's site says Sprouts began in Bronxville in early 2023 and is now part of Gather, with programs for children from 9 months to age 7. The camps and after-school classes for older kids build on that start.
The rest of the store is worth a look while a piece dries. The book inventory covers fantasy, science fiction, historical fiction, mystery, horror, romance and literary fiction. There are also children's books, cookbooks, and nonfiction on history and politics. The shop runs several book clubs organized by genre and hosts author discussions and talks. The full coffee bar is listed as coming soon, and house tea is served in the meantime.
The makers' market has a local roster. Gather's Meet Our Makers page lists Adrianna Gardini, Eden Weisbond of Crestwood Ceramics, Edward Myder, Erica Ianuzzi of Wilder Ceramics, Giselle Reiter, Jani Morales, Jessica Potenza, Kate Poland Hetman, Kim White and Lourdes Aviles as members, mentors and market artists. If you would rather buy a finished piece than paint one, these makers are the place to start, and some of them likely made the bisque you would have painted.
Gather also hosts small groups. A 90-minute private creative event costs $450 per table of six and can take up to 18 guests. Activities include pottery painting, wreaths and flower crowns. A caregiver must stay on site for children under 8. For an office group or a December get-together, a $450 table of six works out to $75 a head, everyone leaves with something they made, and nobody has to host.
Gather is part of a stretch of Main Street that has been turning over this year. Down the street at 25 Main, Growlers Beer Bistro closed in December after five years, Westchester Magazine reported in March, and brothers Chris and J.B. Gomez, co-owners of Climbing Wolf Coffee and Beer in Dobbs Ferry, took the space for a second location, Climbing Wolf Kitchen, Coffee, and Beer, with a larger food menu than the original. The Village's Sign and Awning Board approved the restaurant's signs on June 15.
The next date on the village calendar fits inside the painting window. Tuckahoe Winterfest is on Saturday, December 5, from 3 to 8 p.m. at Depot Square. Gather's Saturday painting hours start again at 4 p.m., so a family can paint a piece on Main Street and then walk to Depot Square. A piece painted that afternoon is due back between December 12 and December 19, at least six days before Christmas.
Earlier this year we wrote about the late-summer rhythm around Depot Square and the storefront-by-storefront changes on Marbledale Road. Gather is the Main Street part of that picture, and between now and mid-December its kiln schedule is the one to plan around.
At Sheila Stoltz, we keep track of the new businesses on Tuckahoe's Main Street, because the shops that open on a block show how it is changing. If you would like to talk about what the new storefronts mean for your corner of the village, Let's Connect.